Q2 Earnings and Hurricane Hillary
While Hurricane Hillary causes SoCal theme parks to close for the first time in a long time, we review the Q2 2023 earnings from Disney and Universal
0:00 From our studios this week in Los Angeles and Chicago. This is green tag them Parking thirty. I'm Philip. I'm joined as always by Scott Swinson of Scott Swinson Created Development. And there's a lot of rain happening right now in south of California. I was gonna say, what the heck is going on? Normally, you know, I'm the one in Florida who has to deal with these these storms and such, and you know, it's now it's you, guys. You're you're stealing all of our thunders and some of our lightning and some of our wind. And I really thought I would get to avoid hurricane season, or at least a little bit of it, having you know, this year where that just follows me. But yeah, I think the reason why I bring it up is because it's a little bit related to some of the themes we've been talking about, and of course the industry, as the Hole has been talking about. Right now, I'm sitting here and there's rain around me, but I'm up north by six Flags and Disland has already closed, and six Flags never opened today, and universals closing early, and Knot's never opened today. So really the parks are they're losing a day on this and they're closing and they had events scheduled in blah blah blah. But you know, there's already a lot of talk about how this was kind of parallel with climate change just due to the how hot the waters were, and you know what kind of created in WHA And I think we talked about well, and they're saying the same thing right now. They're saying the same thing in Florida too, that this is going to be the Gulf waters are so warm right now that this could be a very active I hope it's wrong.
1:32 I hope they're wrong, but they saying it's could be. They're saying it could be a very active storm season, if not hurricane and tropical storm season. So we'll see where that's going to go. I mean, I think it's interesting. Do you think that the parks closed because there was they had legitimate concerns over what was going to happen, or do you think they closed as sort of a visible a visibility issue because you know, again, people people in Florida, we're used to hurricane warnings and we're used to storm warnings, but out there in California. You're not was that? Do you what do you think do you think there was there was actually a physical threat or do you think it was just more a we should be doing this so that people can feel comfortable to stay at home again. I think with any with most natural disasters, I feel like other people are a lot of the threat.
2:20 You know, there's already been a lot of car pile ups and a lot of accidents, and up here where I am, it's mainly runoffs, and it's mainly just the issue of the area is not set up. The infrastructure is not set up for this type of storm. And I think looking at the attractions takeaway, I think that's really that's really what we're looking at. We just we talked several stories ago about the heat, you know, and that being a thing that attraction is not set up for. And now we're looking at, you know, potentially will these theme parks in California need to also look at hurricane type of preparedness and tropical storm preparedness and you know, you know how prepared haird are we are not as our infrastructure for increasing climate issues, and how will that impact our tourism? I think that's a that's a big theme. I don't have answers to it, but that's a big theme, right, No, I think I think you're absolutely right.
3:12 And it's interesting because over the years, the parks and the the building standards for the parks in Florida have changed because of the more the likelihood of either tropical storms or hurricanes or severe weather. So again, well we'll see where it all goes. But the building standards I know, have changed, and things, you know, have to have to be able to survive a category I think it's like a category three or something like that, so they're built with that in mind. It's also a question not only of loss of revenue during the running of the season, but also you know, the loss of assets. So they want to make sure that they can you know, betten down the newest ride, the newest attraction, whatever, so that they don't if they lose a day, you know, if they lose a day of attendance, that doesn't help them, but it's it hurts some significantly less than losing an entire attraction. So I'm hoping knock Wood, I'm hoping that all the attractions in California are are ready for this. Can survive this without any major major issue. And again, it was a Category one when it came when it made landfall. And I'm guessing that it will be downgraded very quickly if it hasn't been already. So again we will. We can touch based on this perhaps next week and see, you know, if there was any ramifications or there were any ramifications from the storm. But but you're right, we have to take into consideration that the world exists outside the industry, but it does impact the industry and we need to you know, we talked about this, you know, a couple of years ago when we were talking about
4:46 COVID preparedness and and and you know, the only way to get prepared is to stay prepared and have multiple paths of of of opportunity, multiple paths of planning, so that you know, it's possible. We may we may even see that. One of the challenges is there is a supply chain issue because of the I doubt it, but it's possible. So yeah, this is just something that I'm guessing. The parks really don't have a hurricane plan per se, but but I bet they will. Now, Yeah, well I wouldn't bet on it, but I would hope. I wouldn't. I'm not sure all of them won't get a game plan, but you know, but well yeah, yeah, and maybe and maybe that her clan came plan is when one comes, we close our doors. But yeah, I'm hoping if there is going to be you know, if there is going to be any potential for wind in any of the parks or flooding or whatever, that they've done that they've they've done their due diligence, They've you know, closed things down appropriately. They may not even have a storm shutter option, but that things are as as battened down and uh and stormproofed as possible. But again, like you say, this is completely new to them. We were talking just before we started recording, and and I made the analogy of its like if you have a snowstorm in Arizona, everybody is is there's a heightened sensitivity.
6:04 Everybody's a little crazy. They're driving differently, they're you know, looking out for things that don't exist yet, but they're planning. They're going, oh, this is terrible, we're never going to make it. So yeah, So I don't want to under I don't want to under emphasize or over emphasize what this could do for California or to California. I'm I'm going to guess that it's going to be minimal. But again, we'll recoup, recoup and recover and then readdress perhaps next week and say, yeah, nothing happened, moving on, Yeah, yeah, okay, Well, let's let's transition over to some news we didn't cover last week because we had so many kind of trip reports to talk about last week. But uh, yeah, we started talking, we started talking and chat and then it just all right, so let's let's let's move on. Sorry, I was about to do it again, wasn't it. Yeah? Oh gosh, Okay. We had the latest quarterly earnings recap from Disney. There's a lot. There always is a lot, and as usual, they bury the leads I think intentionally, so we so I'm going to just kind of go through some of the big takeaways and all the buckets and then we can we can talk about it. But so they revealed that the Disney Parks and the Disney Experiences section, including all the theme parks and all that they saw a thirteen percent increase in revenue to eight point three billion, while also posting a two point four three billion and operating income. So to back up, Disney is not doing great as a
7:38 whole, but the theme parks and this Parks and Experienced division obviously is the part that's doing really well. So that's kind of what was highlighted is at thirteen percent increase in revenue, attendance at the international parks obviously rose, and we talked about how at Walt Disney World it was a little bit of a decline and they're attributing that to heat and drop in pent up demand, blah blah blah, all that kind of back to equalizing nature. They they didn't mention they had to mention on the call of course, and Endless have remained cautious about the future of the park segment as demand appears to have slowed couples with heightened risks to margins and made inflation. We've talked about that too, you know, we'll see how that goes. They did. We did get a number for the Galactic Star Cruiser that they closed earlier. They basically said it would be one hundred million accelerated depreciation charge, which basically is it'll end up being two hundred million of that they're writing off for the Star cruiser kind of spread throughout multiple years, but it'll be two hundred million. So so now we have a number. It cost two hundred million at leaser. That's what they're writing off, a two hundred million, which since there's since there was like, uh not many rooms, that equates to about two million dollars per room, which is interesting. Well, but but also I mean, yes, that sounds like a big chunk of change, and it is.
9:03 I mean, you know, I wouldn't want to lose it, but I don't have to worry about it because I don't have it to lose, So that's good. But the other side of that too, though, is I applaud them for diving in because now they have a whole bunch of data as to how to the next time they try to do something that's this immersive and that's this boutique style. They have a bunch of data that they can pull from to say, here's why this didn't work, you know, and Disney. Disney is usually pretty good about that. They will they will be able to say, here's something that didn't work the last time we tried it, but instead of saying it didn't work when we tried it before, or something like it before they'll say here's why it didn't work, and they'll pull those data points and try to implement them in something in the future. Yeah, I agree. I think we talked about that as well last time when when it was closed. Originally, I just was a little surprised by the number, and I think even I was surprised. I was like, do you know two hundred million is is a chunk of that's a that's a pretty big test. But I guess it's the whole you know philosophy that you've talked about, Scott, which is, you know, if you're going to test it, you need to test it right, because that's the only way it tests will work. Sorry, I don't know whether that happened on your under mind.
10:16 We had a little glitch there, folks. That's okay, that's okay. Froze or Philip did. I don't know whether they did. But we're back together now, we're back. Yes, I was saying that two hundred million surprised me in the amount a little bit, But I think it's uh what you had been saying previously, which is just they had to really test it, you know, that's the only way to know is to is to put the money to test it, right, and you have to kind of question how did they think they were going to earn that back? But that's a whole we could do a whole dissertation. I agree that that's a great point. How how long did they think he was going to have to be sold out basically to make back two hundred million, That's that's that's a great question. I'm not sure how I feel about the analyst section about the future of the parks, because you know, analysts are saying based on the demand slowing and heightened risk to margins and mid inflation. We'll talk about that a little bit later too, with with hiring. Right it's happening now for Halloween, but right, Yeah, And the weird thing about that is it's sort of like an analysts have remained cautious about supply and demand. I mean, it's it's a To me, it's a it's a really basic statement, and it's it's kind of covering their behinds just in case things do tank. But to me it was I just kind of look at that and went, Okay, that's just a sort of a template statement that we just sort of stamp on everything. We are we are happy, but we are cautious because things could stop working. Yeah, well, to me, I agree with that, but I I think it was a little bit like again we talked about
11:52 this too, but a little bit like it's like everybody has been expecting this surgeon demand to continue at the same pace, which is which is unrealistic, right because it I mean, some some some attractions we've worked with Scott have like doubled or tripled. There a tendency you just can't that's not sustainable, you know, to keep doubling and doubling that's ridiculous. So yeah, it feels like we've been talking about that. There's a equalization point the exactly that we've been talking on the industry where we're getting closer to that by the end of this year when consumer spending they've kind of they've when consumers have spent a lot of their they're saved up capital from over the pandemic, and then through into next year, it's going to be a much more competitive landscape. And that's a good thing. Competition is good for for everybody. But but you know, yeah, it's we've we've talked about this, We've talked about this for years, and that's that hitting that equilibrium. You know, it's if you think about it like water, if you if you build up a huge, huge you build a dam, and you build up this huge sort of stockpile of water, then you break the damn there's this huge rush, but that huge rush doesn't last forever, and eventually equilibrium is reached. So once we get there, then we have to, you know, focus on quality, which is why we've also said during the rush, hopefully those smart companies and you know, those of you who are listening, hopefully you've kept your quality high so that when the equilibrium comes, you've already built that fan base with all the people that were coming to you, either for the very first time or all at once. So uh and finally, Disney Plus is still
13:26 struggling, but it's struggling not as much as that was previously struggling. I guess that's the takeaway. We're still in trouble, but not as much yet. That was the whole takeaway as far as I can I can take it. I mean, there's numbers and you know, they they've announced, you know, they're their subscribers miss the estimates, but they're announcing that they're they're going to reduce expense, blah blah blah, you know, all this all this talk, but you know, I think I think basically we're still going to have to see because clearly the Disney Plus model is getting closer to resolution, but it is not fixed yet and it is still in trouble, and you know, that's we're just going to see where that develops. They said they would resume paying a dividend by the end of twenty twenty three, So in line with that, they did announce in order to pay the dividend, they're going to be cutting budgets more than they had previously announced a little bit.
14:20 But we don't really know exactly where that's going to go. I'm not so again back to stuff we've talked about previously. We're not sure how much of that is impacting the budgets for entertainment at the parks, right, you know, and we've talked about that a little bit. How the entertainment offerings are still light, even though it's like, even though the Parks division is doing the best of everything, and clearly people want live entertainment and they need to be competitive, and the way to be competitive is to let people look at Mickey Mouse, because that's your advantage, right. I think like even though all of that, they you know, we haven't seen too much expansion with live entertainment, and it could all be back do to them trying to return a dividend by the end of the fiscal year. So I think that's that's all happening well. And and the other thing to take into consideration too, is live entertainment in the theme park is a significantly smaller amount, significantly smaller amount of investment than it is in new movies, new product for for Disney, Disney plus etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. The the investment is less and the return is less. You know, even though the parks are doing well, that's sort of like saying, our our lemonade stand is kicking butt, but our garage sale is tanking. You know, you kind of have to look at what has the possibility of generating the most revenue. So I'm glad because I'm in the theme park industry. I'm glad that the live entertainment experiences and that the parks are doing well because that that reflects very well on those of us who work in the industry. But it's it's all a question
15:52 of perspective. And as you say, they lead with what they want you to take away as a stockholder, and they want to make sure that you know, nobody loses They're they're not being dishonest, but they want to make sure that nobody loses faith in the in the company as a whole, and that's that's essential. Yeah, yeah, Okay. We also heard some news from the Sea World. Oh, I think we had we talked about how they had they had pre previewed the report kind of you know, where they let people know what was it gonna be good, and it wasn't good. So basically they saw a dip. They saw a decrease in both attendance and in revenue in that last quarter. The attendance dropped one hundred and twenty five thousand, which is a two percent drop from the same period in twenty twenty two, and of course the revenue declined one point seven percent, falling from five hundred million roughly to four hund ninety six. You know, and they're because they're blaming weather of course, and also Conadian wildfliers and blah blah.
16:48 But I think we I think the larger problem that these these parks, and I want to say these parks, I mean like the Sea World in the Six Flags, you know, like clearly, Disney Universe Soul are in that area where when people are making decisions about their limited disposal income, they are going to you know, they're not going to give up Disney, clearly, and they're not going to give up going to Halloween horror nights clearly, right, Like that's I mean the popcorn sippers blah blah. You know, they're they're entrenched so much, you know that, I think people are going to be choosing those. I think it's going to be the parks that are not holiday traditions for families, you know as much that are going to be struggling.
17:30 And I think we're seeing that now. And I'm not sure it's going to get any better for these parks, you know. I think objectively speaking, they'll get more people just because of the holidays, but I'm not sure they will see an increase versus the previous years. Yeah, I agree with you to it. I agree with you to a certain extent. However, I do think that and I'd be curious to see this. I'd be curious to see the numbers on this. I do think that the holiday offerings, even for the secondary the non Disney and non Universal parks, I think that the holiday because the the died in the wool holiday goers, whether it's Halloween or Christmas, are local. For the most part. Universal is an exception.
18:11 Disney is an exception, but for you know, the SeaWorld parks, it's primarily a local audience and it is their tradition to go. I think the biggest challenge is it's a the day product, is that the full time product is not quite as essential to people to consumers as as the Disney or the universals, because again, Disney is one of those things that families make a either a summer tradition or a vacation tradition to make certain that they go and see, we got to take it's little Jimmy's eighth birthday. We have to go to Walt Disney World in Florida, and we live in Minneapolis, you know there. I think it's the day product that really is going to is going to be the driver here because the seasonal product, and I'm guessing this is anecdotal. I do not have the data to show this, but I think it would be interesting to see how does say, for example, Hollow Scream at Sea World Orlando compared this year to last year as far as attendance goes, just taking that Halloween element out of the out of the matrix and see did that did that decrease the same amount as the attendance did I just I'm curious. I'm very curious. That's an excellent point. You know, basically that the parks aren't, well, the parks are are a little
19:42 bit less competitive, but their seasonal offerings might be more competitive. Basically. M Yeah, that's interesting. That's an interesting point. And there might be there a lot too that because you know, as you know very well, you know, the Hollow Scream in Bush Gardens is a tradition I think for a lot of people there because it's been so long, you know, it's it's over thirty Well, and I look at you know, I look at people like and I mean, granted, you are a you are a Halloween super super fan boy, Halloween and content creator, and so you're going to go to the park's seasonal events. Yeah, but not necessarily make a plan to go to the parks during the day unless you're going there for the seasonal events. So you know, I think I'm curious. I would I just be curious because I think that I honestly think that the seasonal events, if it's if it holds true from when I was at the parks, the season seasonal events are the saving grace. They're the insurance policies because they're kind of I won't say money in the bank, but they're kind of consistent in the fact that we know that in October people are going to go to Halloween events, we know that in December people are going to go to Christmas events, and of course, as we've learned, October now starts in August. But you know, well, yeah, we call it October now, but yeah, welcome. Well it's funny because we don't. We don't even when it comes to the production side of it, we don't even think of it as
21:12 Halloween season and Christmas season. It's the holiday season. Start of the season now, Yep, it starts lea July and we're working on it. Yeah, yeah, I that's interesting. I am very curious to see how how those numbers work out. That's an interesting point. I think overall, it's back to what we've been saying which is that all attractions are going to need to be just more competitive in twenty twenty four, basically by the end of you know, by the end of this quarter in twenty twenty four, just more competitive overall because you know, because of the increased basically there's less demand because people do have less savings than they had, and there's increased supply because everyone is finally reopened and you know, fired on all cylinders, which is great for everybody, they're all back. But that's just the reality there.
21:59 There's there's less demand and more supply, and that means a more competitive landscape. And we'll see what the two years of retraining of the audience has done. You know, is it imperative that we go to X y Z theme Park every single year? Is it imperative that we get our season pass every single year? Because COVID retrained us, retrained us all to behave in a certain way. And we won't know that we said this, we said this a very long time ago. We really won't know the impact for at least another from now, about another three to five years as to how much it's changed changed the landscape of the industry. Yeah, well, it's that time of year again, which is that we are actively hiring for the holiday season.
22:44 Of course, that has already started for a lot of places, and is you know, beginning for a lot of other people. There's two stories I want to put together. One is that there's a push from county supervisors in LA that are proposing a twenty five hourly minimum wage, and it's going to apply to basically multiple sectors. But one of those sectors is tourism, and because it's in LA County, it really is going to only impact Universal and six Flags because Disney is not in LA County, right, so so neither is not. So this is an interesting one because I have several friends that work there and they're following this very closely, and their unions are involved in blah blah blah. And the reason I think that's interesting is just because I think this is one of those weird things that I actually think has a chance of passing, only because Disney would benefit from it heavily if it did pass, because you know, if your competitors are required to pay twenty five but you're not, that's great for you, you know. And and I'm going to couple that with a story from Sea to Point which has started doing their job fares for their holiday season, and they this year have said they are just hiring people on the spot. So that's the organized just say.
24:06 The potential employees will partake in interviews and offers on the spot with part managers and positions available from high school students to career professionals. So they are really pushing and we've seen some signs some places where where people are saying, like now hiring fourteen and up. So it's it's interesting because many of my clients, I mean, that's why I'm here, That's why I'm here in the Chicagoland area, why I'm here in South Farrington. This is our third set of auditions for for Terror Roulette, which is a new haunted attraction here and you know, as you know, the Chicago Land area is filled with with haunted attractions, so we had to find ways to be compelling competitive both from a pay standpoint as well as from a content standpoint and a commitment to the performers stand point. So you know, I completely understand that the hiring on the spot thing I find really interesting because you know, again you all know that back in the day when I when I worked at Bush Gardens. We did that for a hollow scream starting in the oh gosh, early two thousands, like two thousand and two, two thousand and three. You could come in and we did in the entertainment department. We didn't do it in the other departments. But if you came in, you auditioned, You did an audition, If you passed the audition, you went to a human resources interview.
25:33 If you passed the human resources interview view, a job offer was made on the spot. Now that pulled away when we had to do and it was always contingent upon passing. It was a drug free workplace at the time, so you had to you had to you know, you pass your drug screening, et cetera, pass your background check. But the offer was made on the spot. So I know that for a short period of time. I don't know what it is now, but for a short period of time they went away from that and have Now they may be coming back with seeder point, you know, but paving the way. But it sounds like they're doing it for pretty much everybody because they're they're that desperate. It's like you need a job, show up, you know, it's it's that and again, like with the twenty five dollars minimum wage for Universal and six Flags, they are. That just shows to me that they're in a competitive enough market that they need to do that, they need to elevate. I'm not sure it's going to work quite the way they think it's going to work. As you say, I think it will benefit Disney more than it will benefit Universal and six Flags, But we'll see. I think that there's there's two sides to this coin. It can either be. It can either be well, wait a minute, I was going to go work for Disney because well it's Disney, but they're not paying you know, they're paying twenty and and and six Flags is paying twenty five. It may I think the intent is to sort of level that playing field. It may bring it, but yeah,
27:03 yeah, I don't know. It might. We'll see. We'll see what happens. We'll see what happens. Yeah, well, I guess I want to know from me, you Scott, you know, because that's all hypothetical. Well, well, we'll track that story, of course, and if there's if there's you know, if something materializes, we'll let well, of course we'll talk about it. And just for reference too. I think right now it's about eighteen, so it would be a seven dollars an hour jump for all positions. And that is that's a lot. I mean, that is I'm sure the executives around there are that's eye popping. So but all that aside, Scott, tell like about the hiring season, What has anything changed about this year's hiring season since you're actively doing it versus what we've talked about previously, you know, Well, interestingly enough, a month ago, I would have answered this question differently. I'm starting to see things change now.
27:57 Originally I was, I was very frightened by the hiring season, and again not just for this particular project, for the other projects that I'm working on around the country, because I'm sure that there are idiosyncrasies for each each area, you know, each competitive niche. And what I was finding early in the audition process, because let's face it, you know the holiday season auditions start in June early July, and so we were what we were seeing then is we were seeing a lot of people sign up, but a huge no show rate, as much as fifty to seventy percent. In some cases, people would sign up saying yes, I want a job and then just not show up for the interview or for the audition. Now what we are seeing is the people are as we're getting closer and closer. I think the fuse is getting shorter and shorter, and there the turnout rate is significantly higher.
28:56 In fact, back at Zoo Tampa we had the last set of auditions, I think we had an eighty percent turnout rate for those who had signed up. So going from forty to fifty percent to eighty percent is huge. So I don't I would love to be able to sit here and say and here's why. But I think it's something as simple as people have come to the come to the realization that gosh, you know, we've we've kind of coasted and they'll be work there when we when we want it. But the reality is that is not the case. You know, we we worked our butts off to get stuff cast, and now that we're in our I wouldn't even say the final hours you know where we still have a couple of months.
29:40 But to be fair, you know here and here and here in Chicago or South Barrington, we're going to start rehearsals in a little over two weeks, so we're I guess we're kind of there, and especially from a costuming standpoint, and you know, the scenic is going up, all of that is happening, So I guess we are kind of at the final hour and I'm hoping that people are recognizing it because we're seeing some great people, but we may not have jobs for them because they didn't audition soon enough. They didn't come out soon enough to get those jobs, so we're having to be careful. And like I said, I like to hire on the spot. But because we've done that, I'm curious to see whether we'll do it next year because now we're seeing the great people at the end. So this is something that we're going to continue to follow. But my recommendation, if you are out there and you're looking to get seasonal work for the holiday season, if it's not too late, audition now, because I know that they're still I've still got clients that are auditioning. I'm ninety percent certain this will be the last audition for this particular project, and I've got we do have other auditions for other projects in different parts of the country. So if you don't have a gig now and you want to audition for it, go, don't wait, don't wait any longer, because people are starting to come out.
30:56 They're starting to realize, oh my gosh, I got to do it now, or I'm done. And speaking of being done, we are done for another week. That's our thirty minutes. So guys, once again, thank you all so much for listening and hope to see you next week on behalf of Philipernandez myself Scott Swinson. This is Green Tag Theme Park in thirty See you next week
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed